With debt consolidation you pay off credit cards and loans with one new loan at a lower rate. In the best case you pay less interest and have one payment. Whether it pays off depends on the rate, the term and your discipline afterwards. A worked example shows what matters.
When consolidation makes sense
- You carry credit card balances at around 20% or more.
- You have several loans with different due dates.
- Your credit score is good enough to get a clearly lower rate.
It makes little sense if the old debts are almost paid off or the new rate is hardly lower.
Worked example: three debts become one
| Debt | Balance | Term left | Rate | Monthly payment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Credit card 1 | $6,000 | 36 months | 19.99% | $222.95 |
| Credit card 2 | $4,000 | 24 months | 21.99% | $207.49 |
| Store card | $2,000 | 24 months | 29.9% | $111.72 |
| Total | $12,000 | $542.16 |
If you carry on, you will pay $3,687.41 in interest. A consolidation loan of $12,000 over 36 months at 11.9% costs $398.00 a month and $2,327.96 in interest.
- Interest saved: $1,359.45
- Monthly payment: about $144 lower
Watch the term:
| Term of new loan | Monthly payment | Total interest |
|---|---|---|
| 24 months | $564.32 | $1,543.71 |
| 36 months | $398.00 | $2,327.96 |
| 48 months | $315.42 | $3,140.02 |
Over 48 months the payment is lowest, but most of the saving is gone. The rates are examples; check your own with the loan calculator.
Three ways to consolidate
| Consolidation loan | Debt management plan | Consumer proposal | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who | bank, credit union, lender | non-profit credit counsellor | Licensed Insolvency Trustee |
| Debt | repaid in full | repaid in full, often with reduced interest | partly repaid, legally binding |
| Needs | good enough credit | creditors' agreement | creditors' vote |
Homeowners can also consolidate with a home equity line of credit or by refinancing, which is usually cheaper per year but puts your home on the line.
Step by step
- List all debts: balance, rate, payment and term left.
- Get quotes and compare APR and total cost.
- Check prepayment terms of existing loans.
- Pay off the old debts directly and keep the confirmations.
- Lower your card limits or put the cards away.
Common mistakes
- Only looking at the lower payment.
- Running up the cleared cards again.
- Paying a for-profit "debt settlement" company high fees.
- Stretching the term so long that you pay more interest.
Frequently asked questions
Will consolidation hurt my credit score?
A new inquiry has a small effect. Paying on time and lower card balances usually help over time.
Can I consolidate with bad credit?
It is harder. Read our guide to bad credit loans.
What is better, a loan or a consumer proposal?
A loan if you can repay everything at a lower rate; a proposal only if you can't. A Licensed Insolvency Trustee can explain your options.
Does the payment always go down?
Not necessarily. What matters is whether the total cost goes down.