With debt consolidation you pay off credit cards and loans with one new loan at a lower rate. In the best case you pay less interest and have one payment. Whether it pays off depends on the rate, the term and your discipline afterwards. A worked example shows what matters.

When consolidation makes sense

  • You carry credit card balances at around 20% or more.
  • You have several loans with different due dates.
  • Your credit score is good enough to get a clearly lower rate.

It makes little sense if the old debts are almost paid off or the new rate is hardly lower.

Worked example: three debts become one

DebtBalanceTerm leftRateMonthly payment
Credit card 1$6,00036 months19.99%$222.95
Credit card 2$4,00024 months21.99%$207.49
Store card$2,00024 months29.9%$111.72
Total$12,000$542.16

If you carry on, you will pay $3,687.41 in interest. A consolidation loan of $12,000 over 36 months at 11.9% costs $398.00 a month and $2,327.96 in interest.

  • Interest saved: $1,359.45
  • Monthly payment: about $144 lower

Watch the term:

Term of new loanMonthly paymentTotal interest
24 months$564.32$1,543.71
36 months$398.00$2,327.96
48 months$315.42$3,140.02

Over 48 months the payment is lowest, but most of the saving is gone. The rates are examples; check your own with the loan calculator.

Three ways to consolidate

Consolidation loanDebt management planConsumer proposal
Whobank, credit union, lendernon-profit credit counsellorLicensed Insolvency Trustee
Debtrepaid in fullrepaid in full, often with reduced interestpartly repaid, legally binding
Needsgood enough creditcreditors' agreementcreditors' vote

Homeowners can also consolidate with a home equity line of credit or by refinancing, which is usually cheaper per year but puts your home on the line.

Step by step

  1. List all debts: balance, rate, payment and term left.
  2. Get quotes and compare APR and total cost.
  3. Check prepayment terms of existing loans.
  4. Pay off the old debts directly and keep the confirmations.
  5. Lower your card limits or put the cards away.

Common mistakes

  • Only looking at the lower payment.
  • Running up the cleared cards again.
  • Paying a for-profit "debt settlement" company high fees.
  • Stretching the term so long that you pay more interest.

Frequently asked questions

Will consolidation hurt my credit score?

A new inquiry has a small effect. Paying on time and lower card balances usually help over time.

Can I consolidate with bad credit?

It is harder. Read our guide to bad credit loans.

What is better, a loan or a consumer proposal?

A loan if you can repay everything at a lower rate; a proposal only if you can't. A Licensed Insolvency Trustee can explain your options.

Does the payment always go down?

Not necessarily. What matters is whether the total cost goes down.